Recurrent stupor is a common neurologic problem and is usually due to seizures, intox ications, sleep

Yüklə 167,04 Kb.
Pdf görüntüsü
ölçüsü167,04 Kb.








Idiopathic recurrent stupor associated

with elevated levels of an endogenous benzodiazepine-like agent

was first described by the Balogna group,


and they then pub-

lished a definitive study of 20 patients with the condition from all

parts of Italy.


The cases comprised 16 men and 4 women; the

age range was 24 to 69 (mean 50.6) years. There was no diurnal

pattern of presentation, and onset was not related to activities of

daily living or to psychological factors. The altered state of con-

sciousness had persisted for 2 to 120 hours. Patients could have

fairly frequent episodes (> 6 per year) or rare attacks (1-6 per

year). In nine patients, the episodes had disappeared sponta-

neously 2 to 6 years previously, after 1 to 6 years of recurring

episodes. At the time of onset of the stuporous episodes, all

patients were in good mental and physical condition, and none

were receiving medical treatment. No patient had a previous his-

tory of psychiatric disorder, and there was no family history of

sleep disorder. Blood, urine, and cerebrospinal specimens were

taken and were unremarkable during all instances of stupor.

Blood oxygen always remained normal (O


saturation > 90%),

even in those patients with some evidence of respiratory disease.

Brain structural studies were normal during and between attacks.

Urine immunoassays and blood gas-chromatography mass spec-

trometry (GCMS) were negative for benzodiazepines, barbitu-

rates, tricyclic antidepressants, ethanol, opiates, and cocaine. The

electroencephalogram (EEG) was normal between attacks but,

during altered consciousness, was characterized by diffuse low-

amplitude unreactive activity with a peak at 13 to 16 Hz.

Intravenous administration of 0.5 to 2.0 mg flumazenil, a benzo-

diazepine antagonist, under EEG monitoring, led to a transient

reappearance of 8- to 12-Hz EEG alpha activity associated with

behavioral awakening or arousal; however, this reversal lasted

only 10 to 15 minutes. Interictal polygraphy showed normal

sleep patterns. Daytime somnolence, measured by the Multiple

Sleep Latency Test, was normal in 17 and borderline in 3 cases.

The investigators reported that high-performance liquid chro-

matography (HPLC) showed an elevation of serum and cere-

brospinal fluid levels of endozepine-4, an endogenous ligand for

the benzodiazepine recognition site of the 

γ-aminobutyric acid

(GABA)-A receptor.


Between attacks, serum (9 subjects) and

cerebrospinal fluid (4 subjects) HPLC endozepine-4 levels were

no different from controls, but they rose to more than 4000 times

normal (cerebrospinal fluid ) and 20,000 times normal (serum)

during episodes of stupor. The investigators thought that such

cases, which they had originally termed idiopathic recurrent stu-

por, constituted a novel though not so rare syndrome that they

now prefer to call endozepine stupor. The condition has also been

reported in the elderly


and in children.


There have been 2 cases

reported outside Italy.



In late 1998, the same Balogna group


reported 9 patients pre-

senting with recurrent stupor, which proved to be due to exoge-

nous benzodiazepine administration. The patients had all pre-

sented over a short period of time to hospitals in a restricted rural

area of Tuscany. Except for the extraordinary clustering in time

and space, these patients were similar to the sporadic cases. They

had the same clinical picture and EEG pattern during stupor and

a reversal of these states after flumazenil administration. Again,

toxicologic immunoenzymic tests failed to detect even traces of

synthetic benzodiazepines. However, since the original report, a

newer more specific toxicologic assay, liquid-chromatography

mass spectroscopy (LCMS) had become available, and this test

detected lorazepam in the blood of all the Tuscan patients. The

investigators diagnosed fraudulent lorazepam intoxication in

these patients and excluded an endogenous benzodiazepine

(endozepine) origin of the stupor. It was conceded that the chem-

ical tests used to exclude exogenous benzodiazepines in the orig-

Endozepine Stupor: Disease or Deception? A Critical Review—Granot et al

SLEEP, Vol. 27, No. 8, 2004


Endozepine Stupor: Disease or Deception? A Critical Review


Ron Granot


; Samuel F Berkovic, MD


; Scott Patterson; Malcolm Hopwood, MD


; Olaf H. Drummer, PhD


; Rod Mackenzie, MD


Institute of Neurological Sciences, Prince of Wales Hospital; 


Epilepsy Research Institute, Department of Medicine (Neurology), University of



Department of Psychiatry, University of Melbourne; 


Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine, Australia

Abstract: Presentation of patients with recurrent stupor associated with

apparently elevated levels of an endogenous benzodiazepine-like agent,

endozepine-4, has been reported from several centers, and a new syn-

drome, endozepine stupor has been proposed. We recently reported a

case with typical features of this syndrome, which proved to be an exam-

ple of surreptitious administration of exogenous benzodiazepine. This and

other examples of clandestine drug use, together with uncertainties about

the validity of tests used to distinguish exogenous and endogenous ben-

zodiazepines, prompted us to undertake a reappraisal of this clinical syn-


Key Words: coma, recurrent stupor, idiopathic stupor, Munchausen syn-

drome by proxy, benzodiazepine, endozepine.

Citation: Granot R; Berkovic SF; Patterson S et al.  Endozepine stupor:

disease or deception? A critical review.  SLEEP 2004;27(8):1597-9.

Disclosure Statement

Dr. Hopwood has received research support from Pfizer, GlaxoSmithKline, Bristol

Myers Squibb, and Brain Resource Company Pty Ltd.; and has participated in

paid speaking engagements supported by Eli Lily, Pfizer, and Wyeth.  Drs.

Berkovic, Patterson, Granot, Drummer, and Mackenzie have indicated no finan-

cial conflicts of interest.

Submitted for publication May 2004

Accepted for publication June 2004

Address correspondence to: Ron Granot, Unit 904/8 Spring St, Bondi Junction

NSW 2022; Tel: 61 2 9386 0290; E-mail:

inal cases had been imperfect and “the endozepine origin of the

stuporose episodes in previously reported patients...should be

considered as still unproven.” 


Since 1998, there have been only 2 more case reports relevant

to this condition. French investigators


reported a patient with

typical features of endozepine stupor who had been prescribed

zolpidem, a nonbenzodiazepine hypnotic for insomnia, prior to

presenting with 5 episodes of stupor over a 5-month period. The

search for poisons, including benzodiazepines, was negative and

HPLC was biologically normal. Although these authors were sus-

picious that an exogenous poison may have been involved and

raised some doubts about the authenticity of endozepine stupor,

they ultimately concluded that “an endogenous intoxication” was

likely. The episodes ceased spontaneously. 

We reported


the case of a 71-year-old man with a 16-year his-

tory of recurrent episodes of stupor and coma. The diagnosis of

endozepine stupor was regarded as secure over many years (2

positive toxicologic assays were attributed to prescribed benzo-

diazepine) until upon further inquiry, the patient’s wife admitted

administering lorazepam to her husband, causing his episodes of

stupor and coma. This was thus an adult example of Munchausen

syndrome by proxy (MSP). 


In cases of benzodiazepine intoxication where the subject or

other perpetrator denies the use of these drugs, the absence of

benzodiazepines on a routine “drug screen” may falsely reassure

the clinician. There are a number of benzodiazepines that are

very difficult to detect using conventional techniques such as

immunoassay screening, GCMS and HPLC. These include tria-

zolam and bromazepam, as well as lorazepam; this last substance

is the only 1 known to chromatograph in the vicinity of

endozepine-4, although other substances may do so.

Nonbenzodiazepines such as zopiclone, zolpidem, and zaleplon


ω-1 specific to GABA-A receptor; they will cause sedation in

the same way as conventional benzodiazepines, but thin-layer

chromatography cannot reliably detect these substances.

The initial and subsequent reports of endozepine stupor all

used immunoassay, GCMS, and HPLC. These methods are now

known to show false-negative results in the presence of certain

benzodiazepines, especially lorazepam, and fail to distinguish

lorazepam from endozepine-4.


The Balogna group



quently used LCMS to identify the surreptitious administration of

lorazepam in cases initially suspected of having endozepine stu-

por. This technique and other more sophisticated GCMS tech-

niques are required to detect low concentrations of benzodi-




Studies in a number of vertebrate species have established the

presence of a family of peptides, which have become known as

endozepines. They are widely distributed, especially in glial cells

in the central nervous system—in particular cerebellum, amyg-

dala, hippocampus, hypothalamus, and substantia nigra—and are

evenly distributed in the spinal cord.


They act via the GABA-A



They are also found in peripheral organs, in partic-

ular liver, kidneys, adrenal glands, and testis.


They are

thought to have various neuroregulatory functions.


It has

been suggested that the high affinity of endozepine-4, like syn-

thetic benzodiazepines, for the GABA-A receptor might explain

its apparent ability to induce coma.


Similarly, its affinity for the

hippocampal GABA receptors might explain the prominent dis-

turbances of memory that has been observed in patients with

recurrent stupor. 

However, experimental work has shown that the effects of the

endozepines are mediated not only through central benzodi-

azepine receptors, but also through peripheral-type receptors and

a metabotropic receptor.


Furthermore, intracerebroventricu-

lar injection of endozepines in rodents promotes opposite physi-

ologic effects to diazepam, including anxiogenic effects,



conflict behavior,


and both anxiety and depression


in rats or

no change in pigs


; it has also been shown to reverse the anti-

conflict action of diazepam. 


These behavioral data suggesting

endozepines may act as inverse agonists on central-type benzodi-

azepine receptors are now supported by biochemical animal



It has even been shown that endozepines reduce the hyp-

notic action of pentobarbital in mice.


There are no examples in

animal or human literature of tumors or other pathologic states

causing an alteration in levels of endozepine or any alteration in

clinical status. These facts raise uncertainties about the likelihood

of elevated endozepine levels causing stupor.


MSP involves the deliberate exaggeration, fabrication, or

induction of physical or psychological symptoms in others. It

usually involves an adult, most commonly the parent, perpetrat-

ing the act on a child.


However, MSP involving adult victims

does occur, and we have found 5 previous examples in the liter-

ature of adult MSP involving conditions other than benzodi-

azepine administration.


Patients in the original Balogna series

were adults from all parts of Italy with no family history of recur-

ring stupor and no history of psychiatric disorders; social and

psychiatric factors were not detailed in other case reports of

endozepine stupor. The ages and social circumstances of the 9

cases that are known to be fraudulent


were not given; however,

the fact that these presentations occurred in a restricted rural area

in Tuscany raises the possibility that they were examples of

learned behavior. 

Little follow-up has been given in these or other reports. No

deaths have been reported, consistent with the benign prognosis

of benzodiazepine intoxication.


The clinical and biochemical similarities between cases of

endozepine stupor and exogenous benzodiazepine administra-

tion, the difficulty in conclusively ruling out the involvement of

exogenous benzodiazepines, and uncertainties about the patho-

physiologic role of the endozepines, all make it more likely that

most if not all of these cases are due to exogenous drug adminis-

tration. This may well include further examples of MSP. In our

opinion, the concept of endozepine stupor, on current evidence,

cannot be sustained.

Endozepine Stupor: Disease or Deception? A Critical Review—Granot et al

SLEEP, Vol. 27, No. 8, 2004



1.  Plum F, Posner JB. The Diagnosis of Stupor and Coma, 3



Philadelphia: FA Davis; 1980.

2.  Rothstein JD, Guidotti A, Costa E. Release of endogenous benzo-

diazepine receptor ligands (endozepines) from cultured neurons.

Neurosci Lett 1992;143:210-14.

3.  Tinuper P, Montagna P, Cortelli P, et al. Idiopathic recurring stupor:

a case with possible involvement of the gamma-aminobutyric acid

(GABA)ergic system. Ann Neurol 1992;315:503-6.

4.  Tinuper P, Montagna P, Plazzi G, et al. Idiopathic recurring stupor.

Neurology 1994;444:621-5.

5.  Lugaresi E, Montagna P, Tinuper P, et al. Endozepine stupor.

Recurring stupor linked to endozepine-4 accumulation. Brain


6.  Rothstein JD, Garland W, Puia G, Guidotti A, Weber RJ, Costa E.

Purification and characterization of naturally occurring benzodi-

azepine receptor ligands in rat and human brain. J Neurochem


7.  Rothstein JD, Guidotti A, Tinuper P, et al. Endogenous benzodi-

azepine receptor ligands in idiopathic recurring stupor. Lancet


8.  Tinuper P, Montagna P, Plazzi G, Lugaresi E. Transient unrespon-

siveness in the elderly: possible episodes of idiopathic recurring

stupor. Arch Neurol 1995;523:232.

9.  Soriani S, Carrozzi M, De Carlo L et al. Endozepine stupor in chil-

dren. Cephalalgia 1997;176:658-61.

10.  Lotz BP, Schutte CM, Bartel PR, Jacobs E. Recurrent attacks of

unconsciousness with diffuse EEG alpha activity. Sleep


11.  Shimoe Y, Fukutake T, Nakai R, Hirayama K. Recurring con-

sciousness disturbance with elevation of endogenous benzodi-

azepine-like activity. Rinsho Shinkeigaku 1996;363:495-8.

12.  Lugaresi E, Montagna P, Tinuper P, Plazzi G, Gallassi R. Suspected

covert lorazepam administration misdiagnosed as recurrent

endozepine stupor. Brain 1998;121:2201.

13.  Huberfeld G, Dupont S, Hazemann P, Adam C, Baulac M, Pierrot-

Deseilligny C. Recurrent idiopathic stupor in a patient: responsibil-

ity of exogenous or endogenous benzodiazepines? Rev Neurol


14.  Granot R, Berkovic SF, Patterson S, Hopwood M, Mackenzie R.

Idiopathic recurrent stupor: a warning. J Neurol Neurosurg

Psychiatry 2004;753:368-9.

15.  Drummer OH. Methods for the measurement of benzodiazepines in

biological samples. J Chromatogr B Biomed Sci Appl 1998


16.  Maurer HH, Kraemer T, Kratzsch C, Peters FT, Weber AA.

Negative ion chemical ionization gas chromatography-mass spec-

trometry and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization liquid chro-

matography-mass spectrometry of low-dosed and/or polar drugs in

plasma. Ther Drug Monit 2002;241:117-24.

17.  Ball JA, Ghatei MA, Sekiya K, Krausz T, Bloom SR. Diazepam

binding inhibitor-like immunoreactivity(51-70): distribution in

human brain, spinal cord and peripheral tissues. Brain Res


18.  Ferrero P, Santi MR, Conti-Tronconi B, Costa E, Guidotti A. Study

of an octadecaneuropeptide derived from diazepam binding

inhibitor (DBI): biological activity and presence in rat brain. Proc

Natl Acad Sci U S A 1986;833:827-31.

19.  Slobodyansky E, Guidotti A, Wambebe C, Berkovich A, Costa E.

Isolation and characterization of a rat brain triakontatetraneuropep-

tide, a posttranslational product of diazepam binding inhibitor: spe-

cific action at the Ro 5-4864 recognition site. J Neurochem


20.  Berkovich A, McPhie P, Campagnone M, Guidotti A, Hensley P. A

natural processing product of rat diazepam binding inhibitor, tri-

akontatetraneuropeptide (diazepam binding inhibitor 17-50) con-

tains an alpha-helix, which allows discrimination between benzodi-

azepine binding site subtypes. Mol Pharmacol 1990;372:164-72.

21.  Patte C, Gandolfo P, Leprince J et al. GABA inhibits endozepine

release from cultured rat astrocytes. Glia 1999;254:404-11.

22.  Alho H, Harjuntausta T, Schultz R, Pelto-Huikko M, Bovolin P.

Immunohistochemistry of diazepam binding inhibitor (DBI) in the

central nervous system and peripheral organs: its possible role as an

endogenous regulator of different types of benzodiazepine recep-

tors. Neuropharmacology 1991;30:1381-6.

23.  Hall PF. The role of endozepine in the regulation of steroid synthe-

sis. Mol Neurobiol 1995;101:1-17.

24.  Gandolfo P, Patte C, Leprince J, Thoumas JL, Vaudry H, Tonon

MC. The stimulatory effect of the octadecaneuropeptide (ODN) on

cytosolic Ca2+ in rat astrocytes is not mediated through classical

benzodiazepine receptors. Eur J Pharmacol 1997;322:275-81.

25.  Mateos-Verchere JG, Leprince J, Tonon MC, Vaudry H, Costentin

J. The octadecaneuropeptide ODN induces anxiety in rodents: pos-

sible involvement of a shorter biologically active fragment.

Peptides 1998;195:841-8.

26.  Ferrero P, Guidotti A, Conti-Tronconi B, Costa E. A brain octade-

caneuropeptide generated by tryptic digestion of DBI (diazepam

binding inhibitor) functions as a proconflict ligand of benzodi-

azepine recognition sites. Neuropharmacology 1984;2311:1359-62.

27.  Zhdanova IV, Kordzadze RN, Pliashkevich I. Changes in the emo-

tionally conditioned behavior of rats under the influence of the

hexapeptide fragment GLLDLK of the protein inhibitor of

diazepam binding. Biulleten Eksperimentalnoi Biologii i Meditsiny


28.  Parrott RF, Vellucci SV, Goode JA. Behavioral and hormonal

effects of centrally injected “anxiogenic” neuropeptides in growing

pigs. Pharmacology, Biochemistry & Behavior 2000;651:123-9.

29.  Guidotti A, Forchetti CM, Corda MG, Konkel D, Bennett CD,

Costa E. Isolation, characterization, and purification to homogene-

ity of an endogenous polypeptide with agonistic action on benzodi-

azepine receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1983;8011:3531-5.

30.  Compere V, Li S, Leprince J, Tonon MC, Vaudry H, Pelletier G.

Effect of intracerebroventricular administration of the octadecaneu-

ropeptide on the expression of pro-opiomelanocortin, neuropeptide

Y and corticotropin-releasing hormone mRNAs in rat hypothala-

mus. J Neuroendocrinol 2003;152:197-203.

31.  Dong E, Matsumoto K, Tohda M, Watanabe H. Involvement of

diazepam binding inhibitor and its fragment octadecaneuropeptide

in social isolation stress-induced decrease in pentobarbital sleep in

mice. Life Sci 1999;6419:1779-84.

32.  Rosenberg DA. Web of deceit: a literature review of Munchausen

syndrome by proxy. Child Abuse Neglect 1987;114:547-63.

33.  Bools C. Factitious illness by proxy. Munchausen syndrome by

proxy. Br J Psychiatry 1996;1693:268-75.

34.  Meadow R. Munchausen syndrome by proxy. The hinterland of

child abuse. Lancet 1977;2:343.

35.  Owen L, Ellis M, Shield J. Deliberate sulphonylurea poisoning

mimicking hyperinsulinemia of infancy. Arch Dis Child


36.  Sigal MD, Altmark D, Carmel I. Munchausen syndrome by adult

proxy: a perpetrator abusing two adults. J Nerv Ment Dis


37.  Krebs MO, Bouden A, Loo H, Olie JP. Munchhausen syndrome by

proxy between two adults. Presse Med 1996;2512:583-6.

38.  Kaufman-Walther V, Laederach-Hofmann K. Munchausen syn-

drome in a 66-year-old patient. Schweiz Rundsch Med Prax


39.  Ben Chetrit E, Melmed RN. Recurrent hypoglycaemia in multiple

myeloma: a case of Munchausen syndrome by proxy in an elderly

patient. J Intern Med 1998;2442:175-8.

40.  Somani VK. Witchcraft’s syndrome: Munchausen’s syndrome by

proxy. Int J Dermatol 1998;373:229-30.

Endozepine Stupor: Disease or Deception? A Critical Review—Granot et al

SLEEP, Vol. 27, No. 8, 2004


Kataloq: Articles
Articles -> Dişlərin çəkilməsi əməliyyatı. Ümumi və yerli fəsadlar. Müəllif: Dos. H.Ə.Əsədov
Articles -> ÜZ-ÇƏNƏ CƏrrahiYYƏSİNDƏ VƏ CƏrrahi stomatologiyada ağrisizlaşdirma üsullari müəllif: Dos. S. Z.Əliyev
Articles -> Üz-çənə nahiyyəsinin iltihabı prosesləri Müəllif: H.Ə.Əsədov
Articles -> Müəllif : Kərimov R. A. Ə.Əliyev adına adhti
Articles -> F. tularensis patogeni aşağıda qeyd olunanlarda aşkar olunur: F. tularensis patogeni aşağıda qeyd olunanlarda aşkar olunur
Articles -> Qara ciyərin xərçəngi Ə.Əliyev ad. Az. Hti
Articles -> Əhalinin 5-10% təsadüf edilir
Articles -> Yersinia pestis bakteriyası ilə yüksək ölümcül yoluxucu xəstəlik

Yüklə 167,04 Kb.

Dostları ilə paylaş:

Verilənlər bazası müəlliflik hüququ ilə müdafiə olunur © 2022
rəhbərliyinə müraciət

    Ana səhifə